You're Doing Position Sizing Wrong | Here's How to Fix It
By Team Agora Circle
Written by the Agora Circle editorial team. Educational content, explained for the Indian market. Not investment advice.
Published 30 Oct 2026
The biggest losses in trading rarely come when traders are wrong, they come when traders are sure, when the chart is clean, the news agrees and the temptation is to double the size. This episode of Master Your Risk asks whether high conviction justifies a bigger position, and answers yes, but only within a limit that protects the account. It compares four mainstream sizing methods. Fixed fraction risks the same percentage per trade and shrinks size automatically in a drawdown. The Kelly Criterion gives the theoretically ideal bet but depends on inputs that traders overestimate, so serious users take only a half or a quarter of it. Volatility adjusted sizing trades smaller where markets move more, and the Martingale approach of doubling after losses is shown to reach a 64% loss in seven trades. The practical part translates all of this into Indian F&O rules for defined risk and undefined risk trades, total deployment in normal and high volatility markets, and a proof of concept step before sizing up. The video ends by noting that SEBI's data shows nine out of ten F&O traders in loss, mostly wrong on size rather than direction, and that even a casino with a 3 to 5% edge caps your bet on a single hand.
Key takeaways
- The problem is not conviction, it is conviction deciding the size of the trade. Position sizing is not a part of risk management, it is risk management.
- Four mainstream methods are compared: fixed fraction, the Kelly Criterion, volatility adjusted sizing and the Martingale trap.
- Fixed fraction risks the same percentage of the account on every trade, so size shrinks automatically in a drawdown. A 10 lakh account risking 1% risks ₹10,000, and an 8 lakh account risks ₹8,000.
- Kelly gives the theoretically best bet size but needs accurate inputs, and traders tend to overestimate their edge, so even serious users bet half or a quarter of what the formula says. In an efficient market like Nifty, a perceived edge is mostly an illusion.
- Volatility adjusted sizing trades smaller in volatile markets so every position carries roughly equal risk. Bank Nifty moves more than Nifty, so the same capital should use a smaller size there. It looks backwards, so it works best combined with fixed fraction.
- Martingale, doubling after each loss, starts at 1% and reaches a 64% loss in just seven trades, and seven losses in a row is not rare. It only works with infinite money.
Watch the full discussion
Frequently asked questions
Should I increase position size when conviction is high?
The video's answer is yes, but only inside a limit. A one off 2x or 3x can be reasonable, while 5x or 10x is a non starter. The limit is what stops a ten out of ten conviction trade from taking down the whole account.
What sizing rules does the video suggest for Indian F&O?
For defined risk trades such as option buying and spreads, where the maximum loss is known, it suggests risking roughly half a percent to 1.5% of capital per trade. For undefined risk trades such as naked option selling, it suggests keeping margin at about 3% to 7% of capital. Total deployment should stay around 30% to 50% in normal times and 40% to 65% when volatility is high and premiums are expensive.
How do I earn the right to size up?
The fourth rule is proof of concept: show results at your current size level for at least three months before moving to the next step. In the host's risk framework this is the S, for size, which works as the permission layer.
Why is Martingale so dangerous?
Because the doubling compounds faster than any account can absorb. Starting at a 1% loss and doubling gives 2%, 4%, 8%, 16%, 32% and then 64% after seven losses in a row, which wipes out the account. It only works if you have infinite money, and nobody does.