You're Reading Your 100 Trades Wrong (Here's How To Fix It)
By Team Agora Circle
Written by the Agora Circle editorial team. Educational content, explained for the Indian market. Not investment advice.
Published 6 Nov 2026
The previous episode in this series gave simple advice, pick one setup, take 100 trades and journal every one of them. This video is about the step where most traders go wrong next, which is looking only at profit and loss and then either celebrating or abandoning a strategy. It turns the 100 trades into a report card of five tests. Expectancy comes first, because a 42% win rate with 2.1R average winners and 1R average losers is a positive system. Net expectancy then subtracts costs, which can shrink a thin edge, and rule adherence separates trades that followed the plan from those that did not, so you can tell whether a strategy or the trader is failing. The remaining tests check whether you can survive losing streaks and whether the setup works across market regimes. The results lead to one of three verdicts, scale, refine or drop, and the video recommends checking rolling expectancy every 20 trades afterwards. A free Excel scorecard accompanies the video, and every figure shown is an example rather than a real result.
Key takeaways
- P&L alone does not tell you whether a strategy has an edge. A set of 100 journaled trades needs a report card of five tests and one verdict.
- Expectancy beats win rate. In the video's example, 42 winners averaging 2.1R and 58 losers averaging 1R give plus 0.3R per trade before costs, so a 42% win rate can still be a positive system.
- Net expectancy after costs is a separate test. With a cost of 0.1R per trade, the example edge drops from 0.3R to 0.2R, and trading more means paying more, so thin edges can disappear.
- Split rule based trades from rule broken trades. In the example, 70 trades that followed the rules made plus 0.5R each while 30 that broke the rules lost 0.40R each, so the problem was execution, not the strategy.
- Check that you can survive losing streaks and whether the setup works across market regimes, then decide whether to scale, refine or drop the setup.
- Re-check rolling expectancy every 20 trades so you notice when an edge is fading. All numbers in the video are examples, not real results.
Watch the full discussion
Frequently asked questions
What are the five tests for 100 trades?
Expectancy, net expectancy after costs, rule based versus rule broken trades, survival through losing streaks, and a market regime filter. The video then turns the results into one of three verdicts: scale, refine or drop the setup.
Why look at net expectancy after costs?
Because costs are charged on every trade regardless of the result. In the video's example a 0.1R cost per trade cuts a 0.3R edge to 0.2R. It also references SEBI's FY26 study, which showed that trading costs push many traders from gross profit into a net loss.
What is the difference between a good loss and a bad loss?
A good loss comes from a trade that followed the plan and simply did not work, which is a normal cost of running a strategy with an edge. A bad loss comes from a trade that broke the rules. Separating the two shows whether the strategy or your execution is the real problem.
Where do I get the scorecard?
The video's description links a free 100 Trade Edge Scorecard in Excel. You enter your 100 trades and it produces the verdict, and it is listed with this video's resources.