Agora Circle
Trading Tools & Edge

Why A 90% Win Rate Can Still Lose Money | Trading Expectancy Explained

By Team Agora Circle

Written by the Agora Circle editorial team. Educational content, explained for the Indian market. Not investment advice.

Published 2 Oct 2026

Two traders, one with a 90% win rate and one who wins only 40% of the time, and the question is which of them makes the money. This episode answers it with plain arithmetic, not a formula dropped from nowhere. Trader A books 90 winners of 1,000 rupees and takes 10 losers of 10,000 rupees, which is 90,000 earned and 1 lakh lost, a net loss before brokerage. From that example the video builds four ideas that actually decide whether an account grows: win rate, risk reward measured in R, expectancy and edge. It shows that a trader can lose three quarters of their trades and still break even with a 3R winner, and that a planned 2R winner at a 40% win rate earns 0.2R per trade while the same strategy loses 0.12R if the real winners only reach 1.2R. The lesson is that your plan is not your result and the journal is where the truth sits. The video also uses a Roger Federer example to show that a small edge compounds across many repetitions, explains why losing streaks are normal, and ends with a practical way to audit your last 50 trades.

Key takeaways

  • A 90% win rate can lose money. Ninety wins of 1,000 rupees against ten losses of 10,000 rupees earns 90,000 and loses 1 lakh, a net loss of 10,000 before brokerage.
  • Win rate only says how often you win. Risk reward, measured in R multiples, says how much you make when you win compared with how much you lose.
  • You can lose 75 of every 100 trades and still break even if your actual average winner is 3R and your average loser is 1R.
  • Expectancy combines win rate and risk reward into one number per trade. A 40% win rate with a planned 2R winner earns 0.2R per trade.
  • Your plan is not your result. If the journal shows actual winners of only 1.2R, the same strategy loses 0.12R per trade.
  • An edge can be small and still matter, as the Federer 54 percent example shows, because it compounds over many repetitions. Losing streaks are normal even with an edge, and auditing your last 50 trades shows your true numbers.

Watch the full discussion

Frequently asked questions

How can a 90% win rate lose money?

Because the losses can be far larger than the wins. In the video's example, 90 wins of 1,000 rupees make 90,000, and 10 losses of 10,000 rupees lose 1 lakh, leaving a net loss of 10,000 before brokerage even though the trader wins nine times out of ten.

What is expectancy and how do I calculate it?

Expectancy is the average result per trade, measured in R. It combines your win rate with your average win and average loss. In the video, a 40% win rate with a planned 2R winner and a 1R loser gives plus 0.2R per trade, so the trader with the lower win rate can be the one making money.

What does a break even win rate depend on?

On your risk reward. The video shows that with winners of 3R and losers of 1R you can lose 75 of every 100 trades and still break even, because the few wins pay for the many losses.

How do I audit my last 50 trades?

The video closes with a simple method: take your last 50 trades, measure your actual win rate and your actual average win and loss, and compute expectancy from those, not from your plan. The gap between planned and actual risk reward is usually where the account is leaking.

Related from Agora

Back to Resources